Managing the Financial Side of Commercial Fleets

Fleet Executives Must be Futurists

November 2013, by Wayne Smolda

Yogi Berra once said, “The future ain’t what it used to be.” To that, I want to add, “And it never was,” because technology and government regulations have been changing as long as I’ve been alive, and are changing more rapidly than ever.

For 12 years now, Fleet Financials and CEI have sponsored the Fleet Executive of the Year Award, created to recognize those professionals who provide strategic leadership and mentoring to the fleet departments within their organizations.

We in the business know that the day-to-day challenges of operating a fleet are immense. It requires mastery of the current state of affairs across a broad range of subjects, from acquisition and fuel costs to accident, safety, technology, and more. But, to be a truly successful leader in this field you have to look beyond the present to the future, and be ready to innovate. In short, great fleet executives need to be futurists.

Seeking out and sharing new information is key to planning for the future. I want to do my part by sharing with you what I see are several major trends that are rushing toward us: much higher costs for accident repair, rising risk to vehicle safety from poor repairs, and an increasing risk of exposure to liability for fleet accidents.

Higher Accident Repair Costs & Roadway Danger

I believe we are only at the beginning of a technology-driven increase in the cost of automotive accident repairs and a dangerous capability gap that’s widening. There are several reasons.

First, there is increasing research by auto manufacturers  to drive fuel efficiency ever higher through the use of exotic materials such as new steel and magnesium alloys, carbon fiber composites, and greater use of weight-advantaged aluminum. These materials make the repair process vastly more complicated, which means the labor component of repairs is destined to rise. They’re also going to require shops to make major investments in new equipment and training. At the same time, there’s relentless pressure on shops to hold down repair bills and labor rates.

One potential outcome is that some shop owners will save money by repairing vehicles the same way they’ve done for years. The danger is inferior repairs, more crashes, and significantly reduced vehicle resale values.

Another possible outcome is that even more shops will be forced out of business. Since 2007, the squeeze on collision repair shops has cut their number from 45,000 to fewer than 37,000 today. Inevitably, a smaller vendor market alone will translate into higher repair costs, despite outside pressure to contain those costs.

Another factor is continuing demand for ever-more safety technology. What started with seat belts and air bags is now extending to a new generation of “driver assist” equipment, including sensors that link to black boxes and steering, braking, and vehicle control components. In most cases, repairing these kinds of systems means the more expensive alternative of replacing instead of fixing them, and when sensors are involved, it takes more time for the technicians to reposition them precisely so they work as designed.

Increasing Fleet Liability

Technology is also raising fleet operators’ exposure to liability for accidents caused by their drivers. The greater use of telematics systems is increasing the amount of data that fleets are collecting on their drivers’ behavior, even if they aren’t converting that data to information that helps identify high-risk drivers.

A similar challenge comes from the proliferation of traffic safety cameras. Camera-issued tickets are sent to the registered owner of the vehicle, but in most cases this is the fleet, not the driver, and the violations don’t get recorded on one of the major tools fleets use for identifying high-risk drivers, their motor vehicle records. In both cases, the lapses mean it’s likely that many fleets are operating without complete knowledge of who their high-risk drivers are, even though the data is available. In court, this opens fleet operators to the charge that “you have should have known what you could have known.”

A Community of Futurists

These are just a few of the challenges that fleet executives face. It remains to be seen whether the savings from better fuel economy and fewer accidents will offset higher repair costs for repairing the technologically more advanced fleet vehicles of the future. At CEI, we like to think the DriverCare technology we’re developing in partnership with our fleet customers will help them identify their high-risk drivers more effectively, and that our continuous monitoring of our repair partners will assure fleets their vehicles are always properly repaired.

Being a futurist isn’t easy. The odds are much better when we in the fleet industry — fleet operators and their suppliers — put our heads together to imagine the future.

Wayne Smolda is the CEO and founder of The CEI Group.

Twitter Facebook Google+


Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:

Fleet Incentives

Determine the actual cost of owning and running a vehicle in your fleet. Compare vehicles by class and model.


Market Trends

Mike Antich
The Popularity of Euro-Style Vans to Put Upward Pressure on Euro-Metric Replacement Tire Costs

By Mike Antich
Sales of Euro-style vans exceeded total sales of traditional body-on-frame vans for the first time in 2015. This is an important milestone in the evolution of the fleet van market, but the rapid market share expansion of Euro-style vans will have a near-term impact on replacement tire availability, which, in turn, will exert upward pressure on pricing.

Flat Fuel Prices Forecast to Extend Through 2016

By Mike Antich

View All

Driving Notes

Mike Antich
2016 Ram 3500 HD with 6.7L Diesel

By Mike Antich
The Cummins 6.7L diesel powertrain generates 385 horsepower and an amazing 900 lb.-ft. of torque, which increases towing capacity to a record-breaking 31,250 pounds, the most ever for a mass-production vehicle.

2017 Jaguar XE S

By Paul Clinton

View All

Nobody Asked Me, But...

Sherb Brown
Safety Equipment: Taking the Lead

By Sherb Brown
We bang the drum for fleet safety a lot here at Automotive Fleet. It’s an area of top concern for most of our readers and for most of the suppliers that do business with them.

It's Not Just What You Know

By Sherb Brown

View All

In Memoriam: Coach's Insights

Ed Bobit
Thinking of the Newbies of the Future

By Ed Bobit
A lot has changed in the past 10-15 years, so we can only imagine this momentum will continue into the next decade-plus. How will this change impact the fleet manager of tomorrow?

Managing a Car vs. Work Truck Fleet

By Ed Bobit

View All


Fleet Financials Magazine - November/December 2015

Featured Articles Include: * ADP's Michael Bieger Named 2015 Fleet Executive of the Year * Fleets Face a Rising Tide of Accidents * Ford and HP Using Big Data to Better Manage Fleet & Personalize Drives

Up Next

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher