Managing the Financial Side of Commercial Fleets

The Advantages and Pitfalls of Employee Monitoring

July 2008, by Richard Alaniz

When he accepted a cell phone from his employer in 2005, John Halpin never guessed that a perk would get him fired. But the global positioning system (GPS) in the veteran New York City school employee’s phone contradicted his time cards, showing that he left work early on a repeated basis. Last year, the Department of Education dismissed him, following an administrative law judge’s recommendation.

Halpin, a 21-year employee of the schools who oversaw the system’s carpenters, argued that his privacy was invaded because he didn’t realize the phone contained a GPS system. The judge was not sympathetic, even though that same GPS system showed Halpin often came to work hours early. The judge found that “The department [of Education] is not expected to notify its employees of all the methods it may possibly use to uncover their misconduct,” according to the New York Post. “The undisputed intent of issuing the cell phone with GPS was for the department to be able to determine the whereabouts of its supervisors in the field.”

Despite high-profile cases such as Halpin’s, employer use of GPS tracking is still rare, even as other types of employee monitoring are growing. While two-thirds of employers monitor their workers’ Internet activity, less than 10 percent use GPS systems on company vehicles, according to the “2007 Electronic Monitoring & Surveillance Survey,” conducted by the American Management Association (AMA) and The ePolicy Institute.

Of the companies surveyed, 8 percent use GPS to track company vehicles; 3 percent use GPS to monitor cell phones; and less than 1 percent use GPS to monitor employee ID/Smartcards.

However, cases such as Halpin’s are becoming more common among employers that utilize surveillance methods. The survey found employers are taking more disciplinary actions against employees who flout company policy. More than 25 percent of these employers have fired workers for misusing e-mail, and nearly one-third has fired employees for misusing the Internet.

While drivers and other vehicle fleet workers may balk at the idea of being monitored, surveillance tools can offer many advantages to both employees and employers, such as reducing idle time, improving routing systems, and mitigating risk. At the same time, vehicle fleet managers who may want to consider the use of GPS systems should also be aware of legal restrictions and must be sensitive to employees’ concerns about surveillance.



Employee Surveillance Trends

According to the AMA/ePolicy survey, Internet and e-mail monitoring are the most common types of employee surveillance tools — 66 percent of respondents monitor Internet connections, and 65 percent use software to block connections to certain Web sites, including those that contain pornographic material, social networking sites, and sports.

Nearly 45 percent of companies monitor their employees’ e-mail. Of those that do, 73 percent use technology tools that automatically check e-mail content, and 40 percent hire people to manually read employee e-mail. Another 45 percent monitor phone calls, and nearly half of respondents use video monitoring to counter theft, violence, and sabotage. Less than 10 percent of employers use video surveillance to track on-the-job performance, the survey found.

Legal and security risks are driving more employers to monitor employees.

“Concern over litigation and the role electronic evidence plays in lawsuits and regulatory investigations has spurred more employers to monitor online activity,” said Nancy Flynn, executive director of the ePolicy Institute. “Data security and employee productivity concerns also motivate employers to monitor Web and e-mail use and content.”

Advantages of GPS Systems

Beyond minimizing legal and security risks, the use of tracking devices in vehicles and cell phones offers concrete savings to employers. And employees — at least, the honest ones — can benefit from the use of GPS devices by increasing their efficiency and decreasing their downtime.

Beyond monitoring employees for misconduct, GPS devices can offer a solid return to the bottom line. For example, with a GPS device, dispatchers can give drivers very specific driving directions to a location, which saves time and gas. Such devices also come in handy when traffic conditions or road closings require drivers to find more direct routes around detours.

Companies can also become more efficient with vehicle routing through tracking technology. When dispatchers know where every car and truck is, they can dispatch the ones closest to a particular job.

Monitoring vehicle speed is another way that technology can save on gas expenses while improving safety. Drivers who consistently go faster than the speed limit use more gas and cause more wear and tear on vehicles. They also expose themselves and others to a greater risk of accidents. By tracking which drivers are exceeding the speed limit, companies can educate those drivers about the downsides of speeding, and discipline them as necessary.

Vehicle fleet managers can also improve efficiency by tracking and eliminating employees’ unauthorized breaks. If employees are making unauthorized personal use of vehicles, GPS tracking can strongly discourage that behavior.

In case of theft, GPS systems can also help recover stolen vehicles and inventory.


Twitter Facebook Google+


Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:

  1. 1. Issabele Cox [ May 01, 2015 @ 01:46AM ]

    A pretty great post. In all workstations employee monitoring strategy should be applied. Thus employers can track their employees easily. I think EaseMon may helps you to make it easier.

  2. 2. Richard Polak [ June 10, 2015 @ 12:29PM ]

    Hi! Thank you for a good article. Our company since 2013 is used system of monitoring employees. This system includes components such as video cameras in the workplace, keylogger software Refog ( and created by our IT-specialists program of work time tracking.

  3. 3. abb [ August 18, 2015 @ 06:16AM ]


  4. 4. Letstrak [ January 19, 2016 @ 01:07AM ]

    Its a great article on employee fleet tracking

  5. 5. rd [ November 13, 2016 @ 08:48PM ]

    Is Your GPS Idle Time Data Accurate? Likely it is not and will not be. the reason is it is not measuring idle engine time. It turns on with the twist of the key even in opposite direction when battery is needed and no engine. Listening to the radio or powering up work items via the car usb cigerrete lighter ports use for electronics and driver gps etc... Even if one leaves on the park light s to protect the vehicle or the dome depending on wiring arrangement it may trigger the flag for this report. Warming up the car via the car remote will trigger it and excessive idle even though it has internal shut off time to prevent it in the car from excessively using up the gas. Etc..etc...etc.... Fake reports account for what the report says are the variables to determining idle time and its savings only to you ! - don't buy it waste of money - costs way more than you will save and breaks easily.
    In verizon vehicles - simple using the casr electronic winter starter triggers the report.

    It also is triggered whenever the engine is “OFF”, and the car key is pivoted for cigerette lighter, parking lights , etc… radio — playing radio in car in parking lot and waiting for your big quack manager to get down teh stairs and out of a meeting with his boss — while you wait for him as told to do in the car — will flag your vehicle and you as a screw off —— it shows as idle time — even though the engine was off the whole time — he in a few months forgets whay happened and he and his boss say get rid of you in back room — then you cant reme,ber incident so long ago when he shows veruy old report to you saying you idles engine excessive report = when all you did is rotate key to battery fro radio — since doing so started the incorrectly installed gps unit up as well— thus anytime the keyy is in the slot rotated eiethr way = idel time. Many will have two keys run out to lot and start car in winter — shovel the lot tpolet the cars out for company — then manager thinks you screwed off because idle time is on - afte you shoveled oyut the lot — also if you want parking light protection for car — you could activate gps as idle time - when engine is off - depending on gps install method used. ——

    older company cars where a mechanic tells you to rotate the wheels and engine to improve its performance periodically — menaing just go af ro a spin — even though great for vehicle — the report tells your manage to fire you and he he being a dunkoff will do so without you figuring out 6 months later what and why ot was done —


Fleet Incentives

Determine the actual cost of owning and running a vehicle in your fleet. Compare vehicles by class and model.


Fuel Management

Bernie Kanavagh from WEX will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Fleet Tracking And Telematics

Todd Ewing from Verizon Connect will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Fleet Management And Leasing

Jack Firriolo from Merchants will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Sponsored by

Ethanol is ethyl alcohol. It is used as a fuel when it is blended with gasoline, for example in E-85.

Read more

Up Next

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher